Malaysia

Minister fears ‘provocative’ whiskey Timah aimed at normalising drinking among Muslims

Religious Affairs Minister Idris Ahmad reiterates call for makers to change ‘confusing’ name

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 19 Oct 2021 4:00PM

Minister fears ‘provocative’ whiskey Timah aimed at normalising drinking among Muslims
Timah’s makers have said the brand’s name is the Malay word for tin, harking back to the tin-mining era during British colonial times. – Timah pic, October 19, 2021

by Isabelle Leong

KUALA LUMPUR – Malaysian-made Timah whiskey is now branded as “provocative”, as Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department (Religious Affairs) Idris Ahmad continues to condemn the liquor producer and reiterated calls for the name to be changed. 

The PAS lawmaker urged the local award-winning producer to pick another name as it has sown confusion among Muslims in the country.  

Idris also expressed concerns that the use of “Timah” is aimed at normalising drinking alcoholic beverages, especially among Muslims in Malaysia. 

“I agree for the name to be changed. Such provocative matters, which can cause confusion, should not happen. Alcohol is haram (for Muslims), regardless of its name.  

“What is the meaning behind this name? Are they trying to normalise it? That is what we are really worried about.  

“Prophet Muhammad in his hadith mentioned that there will be people who will drink alcohol of various brands,” he said today after attending a Maulidur Rasul celebration in the capital.

Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department (Religious Affairs) Idris Ahmad is questioning the motive behind naming the whiskey Timah. – Facebook pic, October 19, 2021
Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department (Religious Affairs) Idris Ahmad is questioning the motive behind naming the whiskey Timah. – Facebook pic, October 19, 2021

Previously, Timah’s makers have said the brand’s name is the Malay word for tin, harking back to the tin-mining era during British colonial times.  

Although the makers have issued an explanation for the name, it did not stop Idris from lodging a complaint last week with the Domestic Trade and Consumer Affairs Ministry (KPDNHEP) and Home Ministry.   

In a brief interview with TV AlHijrah last Saturday, he confirmed that reports have been lodged with the two ministries, calling for an investigation. 

“We have been consistent. We don’t agree with this,” he was quoted as saying. 

Today, Idris said that discussions with KPDNHEP will be made as such matters are under the purview of that ministry.  

Advertisements for the whiskey made the rounds on social media after it was launched virtually on October 7, but it has been around for a few years.

Timah detractors have taken to social media, alleging the name is a traditional Muslim one – Fatimah. 

Yesterday, Penang mufti Datuk Seri Wan Salim Wan Mohd Noor called on the government to instruct the brand’s company to change its branding and the image used on its bottled so as to maintain racial harmony in Malaysia.  

Meanwhile, Muslim non-governmental organisation Pertubuhan Kemasyarakatan Rakyat (Pekemas) has called for a probe into KPDNHEP for allegedly approving the name.  

“The use of ‘Timah’ appears to be an insult to Muslims as the child of Prophet Muhammad was named Fatimah, and the launch of the product was close to the Maulidur Rasul (Prophet’s birthday) celebrations this month. 

“As we know, Islam is the official religion of the federation. The sensitivities of Muslims must be protected to avoid racial tensions in Malaysia,” he said after lodging a report on the matter at the Dang Wangi police headquarters yesterday. – The Vibes, October 19, 2021

Related News

Education / 1w

Education Department investigates allegations of students serving alcoholic beverages

Malaysia / 6mth

Lawyer jailed 14 days, fined RM12,000 for drunk driving

Malaysia / 7mth

Loke: No compromise for those driving under the influence of alcohol, drugs

Malaysia / 1y

‘Thank goodness I am a Sarawakian’ – says SUPP man

Malaysia / 1y

Umno youth: Do not make wrong decisions for fear of losing votes

Malaysia / 1y

Fahmi: No change to guidelines regarding alcohol on school grounds

Spotlight

Malaysia

PH denies role in RoS suspension of Perikatan Nasional

Malaysia

Police hunt two suspects after BMW shot at in Sitiawan

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Mohamad Hasan turned away from Lendu nomination centre despite having EC pass

Business

Three Malaysian brands rank among Asean's 10 most valuable, led by Petronas

Malaysia

Melaka PRN: 79 candidates vying for 28 state seats

Malaysia

Melaka PRN: Adly Zahari faces three challengers in Bukit Katil

Malaysia

Shuhaily's return to police force remains a ministry matter, AGC says

You may be interested

Malaysia

Shuhaily’s return to police force awaits King’s consent - IGP

Malaysia

Selangor Sultan contracts Influenza A, state honours ceremony postponed to Nov 7

Malaysia

Sarawak’s snap polls: A clean sweep for Abang Jo’s GPS?

Malaysia

Malaysia contributes €1.6m to international anti-corruption academy since 2012

Malaysia

Anthony Loke: New trains expected to arrive over the next six months to two years

Malaysia

Anwar pledges university access for pondok students

Malaysia

Fake boss orders RM486,000 transfer in company scam

Malaysia

Melaka PRN: Adly Zahari faces three challengers in Bukit Katil